Socialist Mamdani faces backlash over mother Mira Nair's $2-million house

With only four months remaining until New York City elects its new mayor, the race is hotting up. While at least three other candidates are in the fray, Zohran Mamdani, born to parents Mira Nair and Mahmood Mamdani, both of whom have Indian roots, is under particular scrutiny due to his socialist stance, which many deem "radical". Now, critics are pointing to Mamdani and his family's wealth to point out that the politician is too privileged to harp on socialism.

In the latest instance, The New York Post reported that his socialist stance has come under public notice, drawing attention to both his policy proposals and family background. Mamdani’s mother, Mira Nair, is an award-winning Indian-American filmmaker, and his father is a renowned author and a professor at Columbia University.

Critics, including MAGA activists like Laura Loomer and Meghan McCain, have labelled him a "nepo baby", pointing to his elite education and family wealth, with posts on X estimating his parents’ net worth between $2 million and $10 million.

The 33-year-old Democratic socialist and New York State Assembly member from Astoria, is a prominent contender in the 2025 New York City mayoral race, and has been in the limelight for advocating for sweeping changes to address economic inequality in the city. Among his radical plans is a hefty tax on the superrich.

Mamdani's candidacy could mark a milestone: he could be New York City's first Muslim mayor, and one who has roots in India.

HOW PRIVILEGED IS MAMDANI?

The scrutiny surrounding Mamdani’s socialist stance stems from his privileged background, which critics argue undercuts his working-class image.

His mother, acclaimed filmmaker Mira Nair, known for films like Monsoon Wedding and The Namesake, owned a high-end loft at 420 W. 25th St. in Manhattan’s West Chelsea from 2008 to 2019, purchased for $1.375 million and sold for $1.45 million, with a current estimated value of $1.9 million, according to realestate firm Redfin.

The loft, featuring 12-foot ceilings, a Schiffini-designed kitchen, and a spa-like en-suite bathroom, contrasts with Mamdani’s narrative of advocating for the economically disadvantaged, his critics allege.

Additionally, Mamdani owns a 4-acre plot in Uganda, valued at $150,000-$250,000, acquired in 2012, according to his 2024 New York Legislative Ethics Commission disclosure.

This perception challenges his authenticity as a socialist advocating for wealth redistribution.

MAMDANI'S PRIVILEGED UPBRINGING NOW IN FOCUS

Mamdani's socialist principles may invite scepticism due to the tension between his personal circumstances and his public advocacy.

His family's wealth and property ownership, particularly in a high-value Manhattan neighbourhood, could be seen as contradictory to his calls for taxing the rich, prompting accusations of hypocrisy.

Many argue that his privileged upbringing, marked by elite schooling and a culturally prominent family, distances him from the working-class struggles he champions.

Furthermore, his radical policies, such as fare-free buses and city-run grocery stores, have been criticised as unrealistic by both moderates and conservatives, who view them as pandering to progressive voters rather than offering practical solutions.

This disconnect fuels doubts about whether Mamdani's socialism is a genuine commitment or a strategic political posture.

Despite these criticisms, Mamdani's campaign has resonated with younger, progressive, and immigrant communities, particularly New York City’s Muslim population, which exceeds 350,000 registered voters.

His viral social media presence has amplified his message of affordability and equity.

Mamdani, who lives in a rent-stabilised one-bedroom apartment in Queens (estimated rent: $2,500/month), positions himself as a champion of the working class, distancing his personal lifestyle from his family’s wealth.

His campaign's success, raising $8 million with significant public matching funds, underscores his grassroots appeal.

WHAT ARE MAMDANI'S SOCIALIST PROPOSALS?

Mamdani has proposed rent freezes, affordable housing, and a property tax overhaul to shift burdens from lower-income outer-borough homeowners to wealthier Manhattan neighbourhoods.

Mamdani's campaign focusses on rectifying the city’s skewed property tax system, which he argues unfairly benefits owners of high-value properties in affluent areas.

His proposal seeks to lower taxes for homeowners in neighbourhoods like Jamaica and Brownsville while increasing rates for upscale properties, such as those in Manhattan’s wealthiest enclaves.

He also champions freezing rents on stabilised units and building 200,000 units of publicly owned housing over the next decade, funded by taxing the rich and corporations.

While Mamdani rode his popularity and promises to emerge as the democratic candidate for the NYC mayoral election, he faces a major challenge as his privileged upbringing and his family's wealth are being used to label him a "hypocrite".

- Ends