Nikhil Gupta was sentenced on Friday to 19 years and seven months in a US federal prison for his role in a foiled plot to kill US-based Sikh terrorist Gurpatwant Singh Pannun. Gupta can still seek to challenge his conviction or shorten his prison term, but what he can raise on appeal depends in part on the terms of his plea agreement.
US District Judge Victor Marrero handed down the 235-month sentence in New York. Gupta, 55, pleaded guilty in February to murder-for-hire, conspiracy to commit murder-for-hire and conspiracy to commit money laundering. Marrero said Gupta faces deportation to India after serving his sentence.
CAN NIKHIL GUPTA APPEAL?
Gupta could file an appeal with the US Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit. A notice of appeal is generally due within 14 days of the judgment being entered.
His guilty plea limits the issues he can raise, and any appeal waiver in his plea agreement could narrow them further. A challenge to whether he entered the plea knowingly and voluntarily may still be possible. Whether he can challenge a sentencing calculation would depend on the scope of any waiver.
Gupta could also ask the court that sentenced him to set aside or correct the judgment under Section 2255 of US federal law. That route is available for claims such as a constitutional violation.
For example, he could argue that deficient legal advice led him to plead guilty, though he would have to show how it affected his decision. The filing period generally runs for one year from the date the conviction becomes final, with exceptions.
COULD HIS PRISON TERM BE CUT?
Under Rule 35, the sentencing court has 14 days from sentencing to correct a clear error, such as an arithmetic mistake. The rule also allows a later reduction if federal prosecutors request one because Gupta provided substantial assistance after sentencing in investigating or prosecuting someone else.
Gupta could seek compassionate release if extraordinary and compelling circumstances arise, such as a serious medical condition. He would first have to ask the prison warden to make the request.
He could then apply to the sentencing court once he exhausts the prison system’s administrative process or 30 days pass from the warden’s receipt of his request, whichever comes first. The judge would also weigh factors including the seriousness of the offence.
He could also petition the US president for a commutation, which could shorten his prison term. Justice Department rules generally call for applicants to pursue available court or administrative remedies first, except in exceptional circumstances.
A pardon is a separate form of clemency, and the department generally requires applicants seeking one to wait at least five years after release.
- Ends

50 minutes ago
